Choose a welding wire where you can and a covered electrode where you must. Wire processes work continuously and are therefore more productive, but they need gas shielding and are hardly usable outdoors. Covered electrodes work anywhere, including outdoors and in places that are difficult to reach.
The difference in practice
A covered electrode is about 350 millimetres long. Once it has burned down, the welder has to stop, remove the stub from the electrode holder and insert a new electrode. Each change takes a number of seconds. A welding wire comes on a spool of 5 to 16 kilos and is fed continuously, which eliminates those interruptions. In a workshop where series are produced, that difference adds up.
On the other hand, MIG, MAG and TIG work with a shielding gas. Outdoors, the wind blows the gas shield away, making the weld porous. A covered electrode creates its own protection through its coating and does not have that problem. For repairs in the field, on machines that cannot be brought indoors, the electrode therefore remains the practical choice.
Situation Preference Why Series production in a hall Welding wire Continuous process, no stops to change electrodes Repair in the field Covered electrode No gas shielding required Thin-walled work and root passes TIG rod Controlled, clean result Thick plates, high deposition rate MIG/MAG wire High productivity Positions that are difficult to reach Covered electrode Compact equipment, no gas hose Varied, unknown jobs Covered electrode Versatile range What this means for your product range
Many companies need both. A sugar factory or food processing company welds rollers and components indoors with wire, but repairs harvesting and transport machinery outdoors with electrodes. The same application then calls for two versions of the same product concept. Hardfacing is an example of this, which we supply both as electrodes and in wire form.
When making your choice, also take the available equipment into account. Wire welding requires a wire feeder, a gas cylinder and a suitable power source. Electrode welding only requires a power source and an electrode holder. At locations where the equipment needs to stay simple, that is a decisive argument.
Terms you will come across
- Covered electrode welding is also referred to as stick welding, MMA or SMAW
- MIG/MAG welding is referred to as GMAW, TIG welding as GTAW
- Flux-cored wires are referred to as FCAW, metal-cored wires as MCAW
These terms refer to the same process and are used interchangeably in data sheets and standards. Our product pages always state the process for which the product is intended.
We are happy to help you determine the right combination of process and product for your workshop.














